Cocktail Bar in

If you’re in downtown Orlando and craving a cocktail with character, look no further than Mathers Social Gathering. This speakeasy-style bar is like stepping back into the 1920s with its prohibition-era vibes, cozy atmosphere, and an impressive array of craft cocktails that’ll make you want to toast to the good life.

Oh, and during Christmas? The place absolutely glows! Think twinkling lights, warm ambiance, and a festive flair that feels straight out of a holiday movie.

But let’s not ignore the elephant in the room—downtown Orlando can be, well, a little sketchy at times. So while you’re enjoying your perfectly mixed drink, stay street-smart and maybe plan a rideshare instead of parking. Trust me, it’s worth it for Mathers’ happy hour, which runs Wednesday through Saturday from 4 to 7 PM. (Half off all cocktails? Yes, please!)

Now, let’s get into what you’re really here for: the drinks. With a menu as crafty as their cocktails, here’s the rundown of some signature sips, including a couple of gems that aren’t even on the menu anymore.

---

The Cocktails: From Bathtub Gin to Hidden Gems

1. Bathtub Gin

A whimsical drink served in a mini bathtub glass with a floating rubber ducky. It’s cute, it’s Instagram-worthy, and it’s got a zesty lemon kick. The flavor? Decent, but nothing earth-shattering. Order it for the novelty, stay for the adorable photo op.

2. Toasted Almond (Off-Menu Favorite)

This one’s a classic that’s sadly no longer listed—but pro tip: ask the bartender to whip it up, and they’ll oblige. Creamy, nutty, and downright divine, the Toasted Almond is hands-down my favorite. It’s like being part of a secret club every time you order it.

3. Strawberry Fields

The best strawberry cocktail I’ve ever had, full stop. With just the right balance of sweetness and citrusy brightness, this one’s a crowd-pleaser. Plus, the garnish is as pretty as the drink itself. If you like strawberries, don’t sleep on this one.

4. Watermelon Mojito

Exactly what it says on the tin: a mojito with watermelon. It’s refreshing, fun, and photogenic. While it’s not groundbreaking, it’s a solid choice if you’re in the mood for something light and summery.

5. Jalisco Passion

Imagine a margarita with a jalapeño twist, served in a chic short glass with tahini rimmed on top. The spicy kick is just enough to keep things interesting without overpowering the drink. Perfect for anyone who likes their cocktails with a bit of flair.

6. Mathers Fizz

This sparkling concoction is a fizzy delight with basil, cucumber, and lime. It’s light, refreshing, and a great palate cleanser—but it didn’t quite steal the show for me. Still, worth a try if you’re feeling bubbly.

7. Blueberry Basil Gimlet

A refreshing, timeless cocktail served tall with crushed ice. The combination of basil and blueberry is unexpectedly delightful, and it’s a standout choice for a hot Orlando evening.

---

Why Visit Mathers?

Beyond the cocktails, the overall experience at Mathers Social Gathering is what keeps people coming back. From the cozy decor to the friendly bartenders and a menu full of surprises, this is a spot you’ll want to revisit. Plus, knowing about those off-menu gems like the Toasted Almond adds a little thrill to your evening.

So, next time you’re looking for a place to unwind with a crafty cocktail and great vibes, head over to Mathers. Just be sure to arrive early during happy hour, order a Strawberry Fields or a Blueberry Basil Gimlet, and soak up the charm of this prohibition-era haven.

Cheers! 🥂